“Farewell To Arms”

You may stage your own war to get to these crispy chicken wings! They’re tossed with
your choice of hot or mild Buffalo sauce, served with celery and blue cheese dressing.
10 wings 6.99 • 25 wings 13.99

Homemade Chips, Salsa & Guacamole

Papa’s love for “sauce” is legendary, but our love of great “salsa” may rival it! Our
homemade potato and tortilla chips are served with salsa fresca and guacamole. 5.99

Peel and Eat Shrimp

Succulent shrimp so good, they’re worth the effort! Poached in beer and served with
cocktail sauce and lemon on the side. 8.99

Mozzarella Sticks

We use 1/2 pound of mozzarella cheese to make these homemade sticks, served with
our signature marinara sauce. 6.99

Sloppy Nachos

We use our terrific Sloppy Joe mix and cheddar jack cheese to accompany our
homemade tortilla and potato chips. We then add shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes,
sour cream and salsa. 7.99

Bleu Cheese Chips

Send those blues away with the tang of this deep bleu taste! Our homemade potato
chips are smothered in bleu cheese sauce with fresh tomatoes and scallions. 6.99

Calamari

Lightly battered and fried to a tender and crisp golden brown — like a sunset on the
briny — served with our homemade marinara. 8.49

Southwest Chicken Quesadilla

An inspiration for any hungry writer, this giant flour tortilla is stuffed with grilled
chicken, cheddar jack cheese, onions and peppers. 7.99

Sloppy Fries

Whoever said “less is more?” As if a heaping pile of crispy French fries weren’t enough,
we top it with our famous Sloppy Joe mix and melted cheddar jack cheese. 6.99

Artichoke Spinach Dip

Sloppy’s own homemade chips are perfect for dipping this warm artichoke spinach dip. 6.99

Winner Take All Sampler

The best of the collection — an assortment of our Calamari, Mozzarella Sticks and
Chicken Wings, served in our “Large Boat” with homemade dipping sauces. 12.99

Homemade Soup of The Day

The chef’s selection of fresh ingredients are featured in this hearty bowl of soup. 4.59

Sloppy’s Savory Seafood Chowder of the Day

Just reeled in, the sea’s freshest ingredients are featured in this hearty chowder. 4.99

Back to Top

All of the following salads are Kilimanjaro size — enough for an entrée!

The Bilmar

We start with crisp greens and hearts of palm, then we add macadamia nuts, plum tomato and mandarin oranges. Cuban-inspired plantain chips round out this salad, which is dressed with a zesty raspberry vinaigrette on the side. 8.99

Classic Caesar Salad

As robust as Papa himself, this traditional salad features Romaine gently tossed with creamy Caesar dressing, and topped with garlic croutons and fresh grated Parmesan cheese. 6.99

Thai Chicken Salad

We top Spring mix with diced tomatoes, cucumber, rice noodles, peanuts and grilled chicken, topped with orange ginger and spicy peanut dressings. It’s “a farewell to farms” for a trip to our kitchen! 9.99

Gulf Boulevard Salad

Blending the tropical flavors of Papa’s beloved Cuba with the Spanish flair of his days at the bullfighting ring, this refreshing salad combines mixed greens, sliced celery, tomatoes, crumbled bleu cheese, and toasted walnuts tossed in our own balsamic vinaigrette dressing and served in a crispy tortilla shell. 7.99

Retro Cobb Salad

This filling salad takes you back in time to a day when Cobb salad was the only respectable dinner salad you’d find on a menu! Chopped romaine lettuce with bacon, tomatoes, corn, cheddar jack cheese, grilled chicken and buttermilk ranch dressing on the side. 9.99

El Pollo Taco Salad

You’ll find nothing fancy here, just a sizeable serving of crisp baby greens, plum tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onion and croutons, dressed to your liking. 4.99

Treasure Island House Salad

You’ll find nothing fancy here, just a sizeable serving of crisp baby greens, plum tomato, cucumber, Bermuda onion and croutons, dressed to your liking. 4.99

Add a cup of Seafood Chowder or Soup to any salad for 2.99

Add one of these favorites to any of your salads:

Grilled Shrimp 5.99 • Chicken 3.99 • Salmon 4.99 • Grilled Scallops 6.99

Side Dressings: Honey Mustard, Raspberry Vinaigrette,

Bleu Cheese, Caesar, Buttermilk Ranch and Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette

Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your riskof foodborne illness, especially if you have a medical condition.

Back to Top

Inspired by Hemingway’s free spirit, these 10” round individual pizzas
are sure to excite the palate!

Cheese Pizza
With homemade pizza sauce and topped with mounds of mozzarella cheese. 5.99
Add pepperoni for 2.00

Sloppy Joe Pizza
Our famous Sloppy Joe mix is topped with cheddar and Monterey jack cheeses. 8.99

BBQ Shrimp Pizza
We toss our grilled shrimp in homemade BBQ sauce,
then top it off with mozzarella cheese. 8.99

Chicken Florentine Pizza
We use Richard’s homemade alfredo sauce, then add grilled chicken, spinach
and mozzarella cheese. 8.99

Ask your server about our daily Pizza special!

Back to Top

All sandwiches are served with your choice of: Crispy French Fries, Homemade
Tortilla and Potato Chips, Cole Slaw, Field Greens Salad or Sweet Potato French
Fries. Add a cup of Seafood Chowder or Soup to any sandwich for 2.99.

The Big Sloppy

Ask for extra napkins! We make this manly sandwich by piling up a heap of lean ground beef, then dousing it liberally with our special savory sauce. 6.99
With a frosty domestic draft 8.99 Add cheddar and jack cheese for 1.00

Cayo Hueso Chicken Wrap

Our Key West chicken wrap is a work of art, featuring grilled marinated chicken, Cuban rice and black beans, jack cheese, sour cream and salsa ranch in a soft flour tortilla. 7.99

Fish Taco

Fresh from the sea is a Key West tradition worth keeping. These fried, grilled or blackened grouper tenders are topped with lettuce, salsa, cheddar and jack cheese and avocado tartar sauce, then wrapped in a soft flour tortilla. 8.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

It would take more than a thousand words a day to describe how delicious this chicken sandwich, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and honey mustard sauce, really is! 7.99

Crab Cake Sandwich

We take our famous crab cake and cook it until it is golden brown, place it on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, onion and a side of remoulade sauce. 10.99

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Straight from the farm, try our breaded fried chicken wrapped in a flour tortilla along with shredded lettuce, tomatoes and cheddar cheese tossed with Buffalo bleu cheese sauce. 8.59

Slow-Roasted Pulled Pork Sandwich

“The wild years” brought our Papa home to Sloppy’s special recipe: pulled pork served on a toasted bun and complemented with French fries or a side item of your choice. 7.99

Turkey Club Sandwich

Our favorite writer would have LOVED this tall turkey sandwich, piled high with swiss cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo. 7.99

Fresh Gulf Coast Grouper

We prepare this mild fish to your liking and serve it on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, red onions and tartar sauce. Prepared broiled, blackened, or fried. 9.99

Sausage and Pepper Hoagie

There’s nothing too fancy here, just a generous helping of mild Italian sausage with red and green peppers atop a fresh baked potato hoagie roll. Comes with your choice of side. 7.99

Have a Havana Sandwich

You asked for it! Sloppy’s own Cuban made with roasted pork, ham, salami, pickles, onion, Swiss cheese, mustard and mayo on toasted Cuban bread, served with black beans and rice, or a side item of your choice. 8.99

Philly Plus Cheese

We let this northern treat slip in! Choose from either thinly sliced chicken or steak with onions, peppers and Monterey Jack cheese served on a warm hoagie roll. 8.59

Sloppy's Black Angus Burgers

We grill a half pound of Black Angus beef and add your favorite toppings, all served up on a toasted Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato and red onions:
• Plain or Cheese 6.99 • Bacon Cheese 7.99 • Mushroom Jack 7.99 • Philly Cheese 7.99

Back to Top

All entrées are served with a fresh salad and warm rolls with cinnamon honey butter.
Add a cup of Seafood Chowder or Soup to any entrée for 2.99

"As You Wish" Alfredo Pasta

We start with linguini tossed on our Sloppy-made Alfredo sauce. Next we add in fresh broccoli and diced tomatoes. Then you make it your own by adding chicken, shrimp or scallops. You create the masterpiece, we’ll do the dishes! 8.99 With chicken 12.99 • With shrimp 14.99 • With scallops 15.99

Macadamia Nut Crusted Grouper

Papa enjoyed fishing from his beloved boat Pilar, pulling in countless huge catches. This fresh fillet is coated with macadamia nuts and served on sweet potato mash with a vanilla rum sauce. 17.99

Blackened 8-oz. Top Sirloin Steak

This generously-sized sirloin is served with a jumbo baked potato and sautéed seasonal vegetables. 15.99 With grilled shrimp 19.99

Chicken Parmesan

A baked herb breaded chicken breast is topped with our homemade marinara, mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, and served with linguine. 13.99

12oz. Ribeye

“Eat up” a little time with our 12 oz. cut of the most flavorful of steaks. We cut our ribeyes in house daily and combine them with a baked potato and fresh vegetable medley. 18.99

“Old Man and the Sea”

You don’t have to struggle to reel in this great assortment of fresh seafood and fish. We serve it right up to you in a fisherman’s boat. 15.99

Mahi Mahi for Martha

Grilled to perfection and served on a bed of yellow rice and seasonal vegetables, this mild white fish is topped with a light shrimp cream sauce. 14.99

Herb Crusted Chicken

We’re not chicken to recommend this great entrée, served with sautéed seasonal vegetables and garlic mashed potatoes. 12.99

Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes

Enjoy Hemingway’s love for the sea with these sweet, large chunks of crab lightly browned and served with seasonal vegetables and a homemade remoulade sauce. 20.99

Gulf Shrimp Dinner

A plateful of succulent shrimp, lightly battered and fried, served with our homemade cocktail sauce and accompanied by French fries. 14.99

Grilled Honey Glazed Salmon

This salmon fillet is served with seasonal vegetables and a baked jumbo sweet potato and brown sugar butter. 13.99

Fish and Chips

Hemingway’s lust for life must have included this lusty portion of lightly fried cod dipped in our homemade batter served with French fries and tartar sauce. 12.99

Back to Top

Classic Key Lime Pie

Nothing says “Key West” like fresh key lime pie! This favorite is topped with fresh whipped cream. 4.99

Bimini Brownie Sundae

This family-size dessert feast features vanilla ice cream, fresh baked brownies, chocolate and raspberry sauces and whipped cream. 7.99

Hemingway’s Chocolate “Mob” Cake

It’s to die for! We top a jumbo slice of cake with fresh whipped cream. Serves 2. 7.99

Banana Cream Pie

He could have written it as The Affair of the Banana — the marriage of a rich banana custard in an Oreo cookie crumb crust, topped with fresh bananas, whipped cream and sweet dark chocolate chips. 4.99

“The Bells Toll” Cheesecake

Sloppy’s creamy cheesy best… served with strawberry sauce. 4.99

Rob’s Famous Ice Cream Pie

This dessert will blow you away! We layer a trio of ice creams on an Oreo crust and top it with a caramel candy nut crunch. 6.59

Bag of Dough

Dough balls fried golden brown served in a brown paper bag tossed with powered sugar, and served with a side of caramel and strawberry sauce… an inspiration to write your own book! 4.99

Back to Top

Hemingway was larger than life. To honor him, we offer our soft drinks, coffee and tea in magnificent sizes ... and the refills are free!

Coke®, Diet Coke®, Sprite®, Root Beer, Orange Soda, Lemonade (22 oz.) 1.99
Coffee (regular or decaf) (14 oz.) 1.99
Iced Tea (sweetened or unsweetened) (22 oz.) 1.99

Complimentary refills on the above SUPER SIZE beverages
Juices (Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit, Orange, Pineapple, Tomato) 2.49

Back to Top